A board can read every word of an annual plan and still not know whether it can be done.
The words are about how, what and why. Whether it fits comes down to who and when.... and in our experience that part is rarely on the page. It's often the part we understand and get wrong.
These five questions are about the plan, and they're put to the principal. The answers can stay at the level of roles and hours. How the work gets shared out is the principal's call. The board's interest is whether the whole thing fits.
1. Whose names are on this plan, and how often?
A good answer is a short list with a count beside each name. If the same name turns up on nearly everything, the plan has a single point of failure, and it's a person.
2. How many hours a week does each of those people really have for it?
And did they have a say in the number? A good answer sounds like "about three hours, and she agreed that's honest." A worrying answer sounds like "she'll make it work."
3. Which term is the heaviest, and what else is happening in the school that term?
Plans tend to be written one initiative at a time, and each one looks fine on its own. The pile-up only shows when they're laid side by side across the year, and look even scarier when you add in camps, productions and Ag Day.
4. What's coming off to make room?
In our experience new plans get added to old workloads far more often than they replace anything. A good answer names something that stops. If you're saying yes to something new - what are you saying no to?
5. How will we know by the end of Term 1 if it's slipping?
A good answer starts with great measures and clear reporting. "By week seven, every teacher has been to the structured literacy PLD day. If that hasn't happened, we'll bring it to the April meeting."
A worked example
Compass Point School is made up, and so are Gordon Bell, the board chair, and Rachel Brennan, the principal. The names and hours here are the ones in the demo plan inside Planning Room.
At the November meeting Gordon asks the first question. Rachel has done the tally. A name counts once for each initiative it's on, whether that's hours or a key action. Across the seven initiatives nobody is on more than two.
| Name | Role | Initiatives, of seven |
|---|---|---|
| Rachel Brennan | Principal | 2 |
| Mark Havili | Deputy principal | 2 |
| Susan Clarke | Junior team lead | 2 |
| Nadia Sharma | Senior team lead | 2 |
| Hannah Zhou | Literacy lead | 2 |
| Tessa Morgan | Office manager | 1 |
| Gordon Bell | Board chair | 1 |
| Parents and community group | Community | 1 |
That looks healthy, and on its own it is. So Gordon asks the third question. Rachel has the answer because she's added up the terms. Term 2 carries 170 hours of plan work, more than any other term. It's also when Hannah's two jobs overlap, and when the senior camp takes her away for a week. Hannah has three hours a week for the plan, and Term 2 asks her for four.
A short, even tally didn't find it. The third question did.
The staffing calls stay with Rachel. The board's question is whether the year can carry the plan, and Rachel has the working to show it can't, quite. So one piece moves to Term 4, the plan that gets signed is one the team can carry, and Gordon can sign it and mean it.
If the same name turns up on nearly everything, the plan has a single point of failure - and it's a person.
Where these questions sit
In New Zealand the Ministry of Education's planning and reporting framework asks every board for a strategic plan, an annual implementation plan and an annual report. None of these five questions is about that paperwork. They sit behind it. A plan can tick every box and still ask for hours nobody has.
Which of the five would be hardest to answer at your table right now?
Source - Ministry of Education, "The school planning and reporting framework", page dated 18 September 2026, read 20 September 2026. https://www.education.govt.nz/education-professionals/schools-year-0-13/administration-and-management/school-planning-and-reporting-framework